Prices at 31 hospitals in New Jersey, from their machine-readable files. Here the median cash price is $6,347 — 31% below the US median ($9,144), roughly 4.9× the Medicare rate.
Lowest cash prices
| Hospital | Location | Cash | Insurer | CMS rating | ER wait | Readmit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clara Maass Medical Center | Belleville, NJ | $3,986 | $21,847 | ★ 3/5 | 142 min | — |
| Newark Beth Israel Medical Center | Newark, NJ | $4,881 | $22,525 | ★ 2/5 | 176 min | — |
| St Joseph's University Medical Center Inc | Paterson, NJ | $4,911 | $3,192 | ★ 3/5 | 217 min | — |
| Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital | New Brunswick, NJ | $5,110 | $22,525 | ★ 2/5 | 206 min | — |
| Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital at Hamilton | Hamilton, NJ | $5,110 | $22,525 | ★ 4/5 | 172 min | — |
| Jersey City Medical Center | Jersey City, NJ | $5,339 | $23,234 | ★ 3/5 | 187 min | — |
| Monmouth Medical Center | Long Branch, NJ | $5,419 | $21,408 | ★ 3/5 | 136 min | — |
| Monmouth Medical Center-Southern Campus | Lakewood, NJ | $5,419 | $21,408 | ★ 3/5 | 141 min | — |
| Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital at Rahway | Rahway, NJ | $5,741 | $23,533 | ★ 4/5 | 114 min | — |
| Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital-Somerset | Somerville, NJ | $5,741 | $23,533 | ★ 3/5 | 188 min | — |
| Trinitas Regional Medical Center | Elizabeth, NJ | $5,855 | $23,420 | ★ 3/5 | 209 min | — |
| Community Medical Center | Toms River, NJ | $5,855 | $23,420 | ★ 1/5 | 180 min | — |
| Cooperman Barnabas Medical Center | Livingston, NJ | $6,839 | $22,525 | ★ 3/5 | 129 min | — |
| Morristown Medical Center | Morristown, NJ | $9,907 | $21,338 | ★ 5/5 | 250 min | — |
| Cooper University Hospital | Camden, NJ | $14,736 | $11,118 | ★ 2/5 | 205 min | — |
| Saint Clare's Hospital/ Denville Campus | Denville, NJ | $20,333 | $20,334 | ★ 2/5 | 166 min | — |
| Saint Michael's Medical Center | Newark, NJ | $20,333 | $20,944 | ★ 4/5 | 169 min | — |
| St Mary's General Hospital | Passaic, NJ | $20,728 | $20,729 | ★ 3/5 | 182 min | — |
| Newton Medical Center | Newton, NJ | $21,752 | $21,338 | ★ 4/5 | 168 min | — |
| Shore Medical Center | Somers Point, NJ | $22,686 | $19,727 | ★ 3/5 | 148 min | — |
| Centrastate Medical Center | Freehold, NJ | $23,529 | $20,355 | ★ 4/5 | 219 min | — |
| Chilton Medical Center | Pompton Plains, NJ | $24,764 | $21,338 | ★ 5/5 | 207 min | — |
| Overlook Medical Center | Summit, NJ | $24,996 | $21,338 | ★ 5/5 | 192 min | — |
| Carewell Health Medical Center | East Orange, NJ | $33,999 | $20,632 | ★ 1/5 | 176 min | — |
CMS rating = overall hospital star rating (1–5); ER wait = median minutes in the emergency department; Readmit = 30-day readmission rate (lower is better) — all from Medicare’s Care Compare; “—” = not reported. Data last updated October 2026. Prices from hospitals’ machine-readable files (45 CFR §180); Medicare benchmark from CMS PFS/CLFS/IPPS. Prices below 15% of the median are excluded as likely partial or mis-coded charges. Estimates — confirm with the hospital. Report an incorrect price.
Price comparison (median)
Typical cash price here is $6,347 — about 4.9× the Medicare rate ($1,300). High vs Medicare. A fair cash price is usually within ~2× Medicare ($2,601).
💡 Asking for the cash price instead of the $65,820 list price could save about $59,473 (90%).
Rough estimate from this procedure’s median insurer-negotiated rate. Your actual cost depends on your plan — confirm with your insurer.
Shoulder replacement cost in other states
All Shoulder replacement prices (national) → · All hospitals in New Jersey →