Compare: Allegheny Valley Hospital vs Forbes Hospital

Comparing cash prices at two hospitals on the 155 procedures both publish. Start over ·

Forbes Hospital is cheaper overall — its cash prices run about 9% lower than Allegheny Valley Hospital (median across 155 shared procedures), winning on 155 of them.
Allegheny Valley Hospital
Natrona, PA
CMS rating ★★★★☆
58% recommend · ER wait 201 min · readmit 15.7%
cheaper on 0
Forbes Hospital
Monroeville, PA
CMS rating ★★★☆☆
69% recommend · ER wait 252 min · readmit 16.5%
🍼 Birthing-Friendly
cheaper on 155
ProcedureAllegheny Valley HospitalForbes HospitalMedicare
3D mammogram (tomosynthesis)$42$38$51
Abscess drainage (complex or multiple)$124$113$220
Abscess drainage (simple)$72$66$129
Abscess incision and drainage$98$90$174
Acupuncture$18$17$38
Acupuncture (each additional)$16$15$28
Aldosterone test$29$27$41
Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) test$12$11$17
Ammonia blood test$11$10$15
Ankle replacement$652$597$885
Annual physical (established patient)$63$58
Annual physical (new patient)$73$67
Anoscopy$28$26$129
Antinuclear antibody (ANA) test$9$8$12
Aortic aneurysm repair (AAA)$979$897$1,345
Arterial blood gas (ABG)$19$17$26
Bartholin cyst removal$74$68$182
BNP (heart failure) test$28$26$39
Botox for migraine$83$76$157
Brain shunt (VP shunt)$702$643$1,023
Breast reconstruction$916$840$1,227
Breast reduction$738$677$980
Breathing tube insertion (intubation)$96$88$133
Burn dressing and debridement (medium)$75$68$166
Burn dressing and debridement (small)$37$34$93
Burn treatment$56$51$129
CA 19-9 tumor marker test$15$14$21
CA-125 ovarian marker test$15$14$21
Carotid artery surgery$745$683$1,026
Carpal tunnel release$298$273$483
Cataract surgery$425$390$547
CEA tumor marker test$13$12$19
Chalazion (eyelid cyst) removal$68$62$131
Chiropractic adjustment$23$21$38
Colon resection (colectomy)$899$824$1,238
Colostomy$808$741$1,122
Colposcopy$73$67$161
Complex wound repair$165$151$390
Comprehensive eye exam$56$51$138
Contact lens fitting$40$37
Continuous glucose monitor setup$23$21$35
Contraceptive implant (Nexplanon)$49$45$115
Copper blood test$9$8$12
Corneal transplant$824$755$1,066
Cortisol test$12$11$16
COVID-19 PCR test$37$34$51
Craniotomy (brain surgery)$1,499$1,374$2,161
DHEA-sulfate test$16$15$22
Droopy eyelid repair (ptosis)$393$361$745
Drug screen (urine)$12$11$17
Ear pressure test (tympanometry)$7$7$16
Eardrum repair (tympanoplasty)$589$540$799
Elbow replacement$980$898$1,301
Electromyography (EMG)$43$40$141
Endometrial biopsy$42$39$98
Estradiol (estrogen) test$20$18$28
Eye refraction (glasses prescription)$13$12
Eyelid surgery (blepharoplasty)$315$289$552
Family therapy session$72$66$110
Fecal occult blood (stool) test$7$7$10
Fecal occult blood (stool) test (guaiac, gFOBT)$3$3$4
Fecal occult blood (stool) test (immunochemical, FIT)$12$11$16
Femoral hernia repair$411$377$584
Ferritin (iron) test$10$9$14
Fibroid removal (myomectomy)$699$641$914
Flu test$12$11$17
Folate (folic acid) test$11$10$15
Foreign body removal (skin)$71$65$157
FSH hormone test$13$12$19
Ganglion cyst removal$224$206$321
Glaucoma surgery$753$690$984
Group therapy session$17$16$30
H. pylori test$48$44$67
HDL cholesterol test$6$5$8
Hearing test (audiometry)$21$20$36
Hemoglobin A1c (diabetes test)$7$7$10
Hemorrhoid removal$180$165$338
Hepatitis B test$7$7$10
Hepatitis C test$10$9$14
Hip arthroscopy$688$630$931
Hip fracture repair$830$761$1,120
HIV test$14$13$19
HIV test (antibody)$10$9$14
HIV test (antigen/antibody combo)$17$16$24
Hysterectomy$687$630$933
Ileostomy$700$641$968
IUD removal$45$41$112
Kidney removal (nephrectomy)$877$804$1,164
Laminectomy (spine)$814$746$1,157
Laryngoscopy$77$71$189
LDL cholesterol test$8$7$11
LH hormone test$13$12$19
Lumpectomy (breast)$530$486$750
Mastectomy$723$662$1,021
Mastoidectomy$629$577$840
Meniscus repair (knee)$519$476$714
Mohs skin cancer surgery$182$167$535
Neck (cervical) spinal fusion$1,005$921$1,410
Newborn hospital care$44$41$58
Nuchal translucency ultrasound$37$34$116
Office visit (established patient)$55$50$115
Office visit (new patient)$90$82$177
Office visit, established patient (level 3)$44$41$95
Office visit, established patient (level 4)$65$60$136
Office visit, new patient (level 3)$55$51$118
Office visit, new patient (level 4)$90$82$177
Office visit, new patient (level 5)$122$112$237
Ovarian cyst removal$519$476$698
Ovary removal (oophorectomy)$592$543$822
Pap smear (cervical screening)$14$13$20
Parathyroid hormone (PTH) test$30$27$41
Parathyroid removal$655$601$891
Physical therapy evaluation$68$62$98
Physical therapy evaluation (moderate complexity)$68$62$98
Procalcitonin test$20$18$27
Prolactin test$14$13$19
Prostate test (PSA)$13$12$18
Psychiatric evaluation$108$99$188
Psychotherapy session$80$73$140
Retina scan (OCT)$12$11$33
Retinal detachment repair$762$699$966
Routine eye exam$32$29$88
Semen analysis$9$8$12
Septoplasty (deviated septum)$446$409$613
Sex hormone binding globulin test$16$15$22
Shingles vaccine$76$70
Shoulder arthroscopy$708$649$962
Shoulder replacement$976$894$1,300
Simple wound stitches$35$32$127
Skin cancer lesion removal$108$99$240
Skin graft$474$434$898
Skin lesion freezing (cryotherapy)$19$17$36
Skin tag removal$51$47$92
Small bowel resection$824$755$1,136
Spleen removal (splenectomy)$745$683$1,036
Stomach removal (gastrectomy)$1,157$1,061$1,595
Strep throat test$12$11$17
Swallow study$48$44$85
T3 thyroid test$10$9$14
Testosterone test$19$17$26
Thyroid removal (thyroidectomy)$754$691$1,004
Thyroid test (TSH)$12$11$17
Total IgE allergy test$12$11$16
Ulnar nerve surgery (elbow)$412$378$575
Urine pregnancy test$6$6$9
Vaccine administration$12$11$19
Vaccine administration (each additional)$10$9$16
Vitamin B12 test$11$10$15
Vitamin D test$21$19$30
Vitrectomy (eye)$636$583$814
Wart removal$51$47$121
Well-child visit$52$48
Whipple procedure (pancreas)$2,094$1,920$2,871
YAG laser capsulotomy (eye)$204$187$335
Zinc blood test$8$7$11

Green = lower cash price. Source: hospitals' machine-readable files (45 CFR §180). Estimates — confirm with the hospital.