Compare: OSF Holy Family Medical Center vs Memorial Hospital

Comparing cash prices at two hospitals on the 231 procedures both publish. Start over ·

Memorial Hospital is cheaper overall — its cash prices run about 23% lower than OSF Holy Family Medical Center (median across 231 shared procedures), winning on 157 of them.
OSF Holy Family Medical Center
Monmouth, IL
CMS rating ★★★★☆
83% recommend · ER wait 125 min · readmit 14.7%
cheaper on 74
Memorial Hospital
Carthage, IL
CMS rating ★★★★☆
86% recommend · ER wait 147 min · readmit 15.3%
cheaper on 157
ProcedureOSF Holy Family Medical CenterMemorial HospitalMedicare
3D mammogram (tomosynthesis)$118$148$51
Abdominal fluid drain (paracentesis)$1,571$432$284
Abdominal ultrasound$1,162$869$100
Abdominal ultrasound (complete)$1,446$955$114
Abdominal ultrasound (limited)$1,162$782$86
Abscess drainage (complex or multiple)$626$844$220
Abscess drainage (simple)$925$355$129
Abscess incision and drainage$626$368$174
Barium swallow study$1,073$762$107
Bartholin cyst removal$1,106$371$182
Blood transfusion$1,801$759$47
Bone density scan (DEXA)$761$606$39
Bone scan (nuclear)$3,220$2,000$259
Breast biopsy$2,516$3,302$478
Breast ultrasound$518$511$92
Breast ultrasound (complete)$518$519$100
Breast ultrasound (limited)$518$502$84
Breathing tube insertion (intubation)$1,713$489$133
Burn dressing and debridement (medium)$1,544$131$166
Burn dressing and debridement (small)$865$91$93
Burn treatment$865$111$129
Cardiac rehabilitation$250$214$26
Cardiac stress test$1,342$1,127$39
Cardioversion$2,062$1,440$155
Carotid artery ultrasound$1,167$1,720$156
Central line placement$2,574$1,123$238
Chemotherapy infusion$454$304$81
Chemotherapy infusion (each additional)$268$177$28
Chemotherapy infusion (first hour)$639$430$133
Chest fluid drain (thoracentesis)$1,806$423$311
Chest tube insertion$4,918$1,210$143
Chest X-ray$347$406$37
Chest X-ray (1 view)$269$249$25
Chest X-ray (2 views)$317$351$33
Complex wound repair$4,750$1,282$390
CPAP titration study$517$705$69
CT angiography of the chest$3,183$4,110$281
CT angiography of the head$3,335$4,110$274
CT scan of the abdomen$2,710$3,348$230
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis$6,005$6,030$300
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis with and without contrast$6,075$6,297$338
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis with contrast$6,005$6,030$300
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis without contrast$5,098$4,658$183
CT scan of the abdomen with and without contrast$3,264$3,502$259
CT scan of the abdomen with contrast$2,710$3,348$230
CT scan of the abdomen without contrast$2,639$2,738$136
CT scan of the arm$3,274$2,983$199
CT scan of the arm with contrast$3,274$2,983$199
CT scan of the arm without contrast$2,339$1,826$161
CT scan of the chest$2,886$3,348$167
CT scan of the chest with and without contrast$3,306$3,502$196
CT scan of the chest with contrast$2,886$3,348$167
CT scan of the chest without contrast$2,515$2,434$133
CT scan of the head$2,646$3,348$148
CT scan of the head with and without contrast$2,687$3,502$173
CT scan of the head with contrast$2,646$3,348$148
CT scan of the head without contrast$2,498$2,434$107
CT scan of the leg$3,264$2,587$166
CT scan of the leg with contrast$3,144$2,587$166
CT scan of the leg without contrast$2,734$1,826$130
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine)$3,336$3,348$169
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine) with and without contrast$3,472$3,502$197
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine) with contrast$3,303$3,348$169
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine) without contrast$3,336$2,434$130
CT scan of the neck$2,697$3,043$183
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine)$3,158$3,348$168
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine) with and without contrast$3,330$3,502$196
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine) with contrast$2,503$3,348$168
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine) without contrast$3,158$2,434$131
CT scan of the neck with and without contrast$2,774$3,196$220
CT scan of the neck with contrast$2,697$3,043$183
CT scan of the neck without contrast$2,404$2,434$150
CT scan of the pelvis$2,962$3,348$226
CT scan of the pelvis with and without contrast$3,160$3,502$251
CT scan of the pelvis with contrast$2,962$3,348$226
CT scan of the pelvis without contrast$2,574$2,434$133
CT scan of the sinuses$3,170$2,587$152
CT scan of the sinuses with and without contrast$3,640$2,882$184
CT scan of the sinuses with contrast$2,766$2,587$152
CT scan of the sinuses without contrast$2,822$1,674$128
Developmental screening (child)$219$387—
Diagnostic mammogram$604$350$140
Echocardiogram$2,017$1,860$138
Echocardiogram with and without contrast$1,002$1,222$101
EKG / ECG (tracing only)$484$236$7
Electrocardiogram (EKG)$484$236$8
Emergency department visit$648$208$69
Emergency department visit (level 1)$183$136$11
Emergency department visit (level 2)$380$208$40
Emergency department visit (level 3)$648$422$69
Emergency department visit (level 4)$1,026$565$118
Emergency department visit (level 5)$1,707$847$171
Epidural steroid injection$1,001$1,360$275
Fallopian tube X-ray (HSG)$760$348$164
Fecal occult blood (stool) test$87$80$10
Fecal occult blood (stool) test (immunochemical, FIT)$87$80$16
Foreign body removal (skin)$612$540$157
Gallbladder scan (HIDA)$2,865$1,947$334
Holter heart monitor$614$366$26
IUD removal$263$434$112
IV infusion therapy$473$254$44
IV infusion therapy (each additional)$279$169$21
IV infusion therapy (initial)$667$340$67
Joint aspiration (small/intermediate)$1,117$206$57
Joint aspiration or injection (mid-size joint)$423$202$57
Joint aspiration or injection (small joint)$1,128$206$56
Kidney scan (nuclear)$9,596$2,214$172
Kidney ultrasound$1,150$892$84
Kidney ultrasound (limited)$989$789$61
Knee joint injection$1,098$280$69
Leg vein ultrasound (Doppler)$1,383$1,828$150
Leg vein ultrasound (Doppler) (limited)$1,383$1,421$116
Liver biopsy$2,241$988$288
Lung function test (PFT)$542$260$37
Lung scan (V/Q)$1,983$2,410$291
MRA of the brain$4,449$3,606$226
MRA of the neck$4,063$4,017$245
MRA of the neck with contrast$2,857$4,017$245
MRA of the neck without contrast$4,650$4,859$343
MRI of the abdomen$3,938$4,283$300
MRI of the abdomen with contrast$3,938$4,283$300
MRI of the abdomen without contrast$3,828$3,716$194
MRI of the ankle$5,522$4,644$261
MRI of the ankle without contrast$4,463$3,716$222
MRI of the brain$4,769$4,283$269
MRI of the brain with contrast$4,769$4,283$269
MRI of the brain without contrast$4,469$3,716$195
MRI of the chest$4,225$4,799$371
MRI of the chest without contrast$4,645$5,882$466
MRI of the knee$5,230$4,283$315
MRI of the knee with contrast$4,225$4,283$315
MRI of the knee without contrast$3,877$3,716$204
MRI of the lower back (lumbar spine)$4,436$4,283$270
MRI of the lower back (lumbar spine) with contrast$4,436$4,283$270
MRI of the lower back (lumbar spine) without contrast$4,058$3,716$192
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine)$4,037$4,283$271
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine) with and without contrast$5,282$5,572$319
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine) with contrast$4,037$4,283$271
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine) without contrast$3,877$3,716$190
MRI of the neck (cervical spine)$4,541$4,283$274
MRI of the neck (cervical spine) with and without contrast$5,042$5,572$318
MRI of the neck (cervical spine) with contrast$4,541$4,283$274
MRI of the neck (cervical spine) without contrast$3,877$3,716$191
MRI of the pelvis$3,940$4,283$268
MRI of the pelvis with contrast$3,940$4,283$268
MRI of the pelvis without contrast$3,569$3,716$227
MRI of the shoulder$4,436$4,081$313
MRI of the shoulder with contrast$4,436$4,081$313
MRI of the shoulder without contrast$3,877$3,716$205
MRI of the wrist$4,645$4,644$330
MRI of the wrist without contrast$3,411$3,716$303
Nebulizer breathing treatment$116$85$9
Nuclear cardiac stress test$6,214$4,800$428
Occupational therapy evaluation$330$238$101
Occupational therapy evaluation (high complexity)$371$262$101
Occupational therapy evaluation (low complexity)$309$216$101
Occupational therapy evaluation (moderate complexity)$330$238$101
Office visit (established patient)$250$59$115
Office visit (new patient)$372$340$177
Office visit, established patient (level 3)$199$39$95
Office visit, established patient (level 4)$302$59$136
Office visit, new patient (level 3)$242$270$118
Office visit, new patient (level 4)$372$410$177
Pelvic ultrasound$1,078$605$78
Pelvic ultrasound (complete)$1,424$782$105
Pelvic ultrasound (limited)$733$427$51
Physical therapy evaluation$330$230$98
Physical therapy evaluation (high complexity)$371$242$98
Physical therapy evaluation (moderate complexity)$330$230$98
Pregnancy ultrasound$1,362$1,005$126
Pregnancy ultrasound (first trimester)$970$955$117
Pregnancy ultrasound (second or third trimester)$1,754$1,054$136
Psychiatric evaluation$338$206$188
Pulmonary rehabilitation$387$173$87
Scoliosis spine X-ray$318$523$58
Scoliosis spine X-ray (1 view)$295$331$44
Scoliosis spine X-ray (3 views)$342$715$72
Screening mammogram$312$350$126
Scrotal ultrasound$1,424$752$99
Simple laceration repair (small, up to 2.5 cm)$380$394$114
Simple wound stitches$391$414$127
Skin biopsy$521$594$121
Skin tag removal$281$311$92
Sleep study (polysomnography)$4,158$4,209$691
Soft tissue ultrasound$1,190$707$64
Speech therapy$227$288$76
Spinal tap (lumbar puncture)$1,155$383$165
Spirometry (lung function test)$542$210$30
Spirometry with bronchodilator$662$310$43
Swallow study$413$288$85
Thyroid ultrasound$1,368$388$109
Transvaginal ultrasound$1,290$900$118
Trigger point injection$774$552$56
Trigger point injection (1-2 muscles)$422$302$52
Upper GI series (barium)$1,162$434$128
Vaccine administration$116$94$19
Wound debridement$881$696$186
X-ray of the abdomen$383$298$36
X-ray of the ankle$559$302$37
X-ray of the collarbone$546$266$33
X-ray of the elbow$578$249$33
X-ray of the facial bones$625$421$39
X-ray of the foot$562$302$34
X-ray of the forearm$549$249$29
X-ray of the hand$559$302$38
X-ray of the hip$519$334$49
X-ray of the hip (1 view)$464$284$34
X-ray of the hip (3 views)$519$334$49
X-ray of the hip (4 views)$587$359$63
X-ray of the knee$622$267$42
X-ray of the knee (2 views)$521$254$34
X-ray of the knee (3 views)$622$267$42
X-ray of the knee (4+ views)$622$274$49
X-ray of the lower back (lumbar spine)$471$596$47
X-ray of the lower back (lumbar spine) (2 views)$471$512$40
X-ray of the lower back (lumbar spine) (4+ views)$542$681$53
X-ray of the lower leg$559$249$31
X-ray of the mid-back (thoracic spine)$459$374$36
X-ray of the mid-back (thoracic spine) (2 views)$459$360$33
X-ray of the mid-back (thoracic spine) (3 views)$527$389$39
X-ray of the neck (cervical spine)$468$500$47
X-ray of the neck (cervical spine) (3 views)$468$360$40
X-ray of the pelvis$521$307$36
X-ray of the pelvis (1 view)$521$248$28
X-ray of the ribs$678$335$42
X-ray of the ribs (2 views)$510$283$36
X-ray of the ribs (3 views)$678$407$42
X-ray of the shoulder$582$389$36
X-ray of the skull$656$409$40
X-ray of the upper arm$647$249$32
X-ray of the wrist$652$302$43

Green = lower cash price. Source: hospitals' machine-readable files (45 CFR §180). Estimates — confirm with the hospital.