Compare: Johnson Memorial Hospital vs Ascension St Vincent Carmel

Comparing cash prices at two hospitals on the 339 procedures both publish. Start over ·

Johnson Memorial Hospital is cheaper overall — its cash prices run about 76% lower than Ascension St Vincent Carmel (median across 339 shared procedures), winning on 262 of them.
Johnson Memorial Hospital
Franklin, IN
CMS rating ★★★★★
72% recommend · ER wait 144 min · readmit 14.9%
🍼 Birthing-Friendly
cheaper on 262
Ascension St Vincent Carmel
Carmel, IN
CMS rating ★★★☆☆
69% recommend · ER wait 182 min · readmit 14.1%
🍼 Birthing-Friendly
cheaper on 77
ProcedureJohnson Memorial HospitalAscension St Vincent CarmelMedicare
3D mammogram (tomosynthesis)$74$53$51
Abdominal fluid drain (paracentesis)$325$2,206$284
Abdominal ultrasound$99$425$100
Abdominal ultrasound (complete)$102$520$114
Abdominal ultrasound (limited)$96$329$86
Abscess drainage (complex or multiple)$158$1,519$220
Abscess drainage (simple)$86$844$129
Abscess incision and drainage$122$1,181$174
Albumin blood test$9$88$5
Aldosterone test$69$654$41
Alkaline phosphatase test$9$96$5
Alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) test$29$353$17
ALT liver enzyme test$9$105$5
Ammonia blood test$26$245$15
Amniocentesis$202$319$120
Amylase test$11$185$6
Antinuclear antibody (ANA) test$21$306$12
Arterial blood gas (ABG)$34$359$26
AST liver enzyme test$9$105$5
Barium swallow study$69$258$107
Basic metabolic panel$14$218$8
Bilirubin blood test$9$127$5
Blood clotting test (PT/INR)$7$112$4
Blood crossmatch$62$184
Blood glucose test$7$78$5
Blood transfusion$119$1,739$47
Blood type and screen$20$135$10
Blood type test$21$14$3
Blood type test (ABO group)$18$14$3
Blood type test (Rh/D antigen)$23$14$3
BNP (heart failure) test$59$359$39
Bone density scan (DEXA)$79$290$39
Bone marrow biopsy$661$995$172
Bone scan (nuclear)$452$2,208$259
Breast biopsy$433$4,714$478
Breast MRI$669$583$216
Breast MRI without contrast$669$583$216
Breast ultrasound$97$631$92
Breast ultrasound (complete)$102$588$100
Breast ultrasound (limited)$92$674$84
C-reactive protein (CRP)$9$191$5
CA 19-9 tumor marker test$36$335$21
CA-125 ovarian marker test$36$358$21
Calcium blood test$9$89$5
Cardiac stress test$224$999$39
Cardioversion$514$2,554$155
Carotid artery ultrasound$230$1,158$156
CEA tumor marker test$33$391$19
Celiac disease test$75$25$12
Central line placement$539$3,025$238
Chemotherapy infusion$160$757$81
Chemotherapy infusion (each additional)$59$304$28
Chemotherapy infusion (first hour)$260$1,210$133
Chest fluid drain (thoracentesis)$384$988$311
Chest X-ray$71$185$37
Chest X-ray (1 view)$66$163$25
Chest X-ray (2 views)$69$185$33
CK-MB heart enzyme test$20$226$12
Clotting time test (PTT)$11$147$6
Complete blood count (CBC)$12$149$7
Complete blood count (CBC) (complete)$14$170$8
Comprehensive metabolic panel$18$339$11
Copper blood test$22$291$12
Cortisol test$29$316$16
COVID-19 PCR test$15$125$51
CPAP titration study$235$685$69
Creatine kinase (CK) test$11$131$7
CT angiography of the chest$588$542$281
CT angiography of the head$560$542$274
CT scan of the abdomen$588$542$230
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis$560$542$300
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis with and without contrast$588$542$338
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis with contrast$560$542$300
CT scan of the abdomen and pelvis without contrast$532$542$183
CT scan of the abdomen with and without contrast$617$542$259
CT scan of the abdomen with contrast$588$542$230
CT scan of the abdomen without contrast$560$542$136
CT scan of the arm$560$542$199
CT scan of the arm with contrast$560$542$199
CT scan of the arm without contrast$532$542$161
CT scan of the chest$560$542$167
CT scan of the chest with and without contrast$588$542$196
CT scan of the chest with contrast$560$542$167
CT scan of the chest without contrast$532$542$133
CT scan of the head$560$542$148
CT scan of the head with and without contrast$588$542$173
CT scan of the head with contrast$560$542$148
CT scan of the head without contrast$532$542$107
CT scan of the leg$560$542$166
CT scan of the leg with contrast$560$542$166
CT scan of the leg without contrast$532$542$130
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine)$560$542$169
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine) with and without contrast$588$542$197
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine) with contrast$560$542$169
CT scan of the lower back (lumbar spine) without contrast$532$542$130
CT scan of the neck$560$542$183
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine)$560$542$168
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine) with and without contrast$588$542$196
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine) with contrast$560$542$168
CT scan of the neck (cervical spine) without contrast$532$542$131
CT scan of the neck with and without contrast$588$542$220
CT scan of the neck with contrast$560$542$183
CT scan of the neck without contrast$532$542$150
CT scan of the pelvis$617$542$226
CT scan of the pelvis with and without contrast$648$542$251
CT scan of the pelvis with contrast$617$542$226
CT scan of the pelvis without contrast$588$542$133
CT scan of the sinuses$560$542$152
CT scan of the sinuses with and without contrast$588$542$184
CT scan of the sinuses with contrast$560$542$152
CT scan of the sinuses without contrast$532$542$128
D-dimer test$18$386$10
Developmental screening (child)$41$152
DHEA-sulfate test$39$541$22
Diagnostic mammogram$80$327$140
Drug screen (urine)$26$354$17
Echocardiogram$306$942$138
Echocardiogram with and without contrast$175$721$101
Echocardiogram without contrast$306$942$138
EEG (awake and asleep)$213$1,040$482
EKG / ECG (tracing only)$71$301$7
Electrocardiogram (EKG)$71$301$8
Electroencephalogram (EEG)$209$939$448
Electrolyte panel$12$209$7
Electromyography (EMG)$78$1,176$141
Emergency department visit$205$1,047$69
Emergency department visit (level 1)$68$346$11
Emergency department visit (level 2)$94$525$40
Emergency department visit (level 3)$205$1,047$69
Emergency department visit (level 4)$300$2,568$118
Emergency department visit (level 5)$456$3,146$171
Estradiol (estrogen) test$49$491$28
Fallopian tube X-ray (HSG)$114$503$164
Family therapy session$81$98$110
Fecal occult blood (stool) test$18$94$10
Fecal occult blood (stool) test (guaiac, gFOBT)$9$81$4
Fecal occult blood (stool) test (immunochemical, FIT)$28$106$16
Ferritin (iron) test$24$248$14
Fibrinogen test$15$207$10
Flu test$20$58$17
Folate (folic acid) test$26$255$15
Foreign body removal (skin)$120$2,818$157
Free T4 thyroid test$16$305$9
FSH hormone test$33$413$19
Gallbladder scan (HIDA)$452$2,455$334
GGT liver test$13$140$7
Glucose tolerance test$12$137$8
H. pylori test$118$526$67
HDL cholesterol test$14$195$8
Hematocrit test$4$61$2
Hemodialysis$301$1,697$75
Hemoglobin A1c (diabetes test)$17$251$10
Hepatitis A vaccine$68$178
Hepatitis B test$17$209$10
Hepatitis B vaccine$57$176
Hepatitis C test$25$316$14
HIV test$33$207$19
HIV test (antibody)$24$224$14
HIV test (antigen/antibody combo)$42$190$24
Holter heart monitor$248$408$26
Iron blood test$11$137$6
IV infusion therapy$64$323$44
IV infusion therapy (each additional)$36$129$21
IV infusion therapy (initial)$93$517$67
IVC filter placement$1,953$11,381$1,885
Joint aspiration (small/intermediate)$178$824$57
Joint aspiration or injection (mid-size joint)$267$824$57
Kidney biopsy$459$1,739$492
Kidney scan (nuclear)$452$1,958$172
Kidney ultrasound$99$319$84
Kidney ultrasound (limited)$96$239$61
Knee joint injection$57$898$69
Lactate test$19$217$12
LDH test$11$101$6
LDL cholesterol test$17$170$11
Leg vein ultrasound (Doppler)$287$1,436$150
Leg vein ultrasound (Doppler) (limited)$230$1,120$116
LH hormone test$32$430$19
Lipase test$12$175$7
Lipid (cholesterol) panel$23$305$13
Liver biopsy$692$1,931$288
Liver function panel$14$241$8
Lung function test (PFT)$140$747$37
Lung scan (V/Q)$452$2,830$291
Magnesium blood test$12$145$7
MMR vaccine$160$417
MRA of the brain$637$583$226
MRA of the brain with contrast$637$583$226
MRA of the brain without contrast$669$583$328
MRA of the neck$637$583$245
MRA of the neck with contrast$637$583$245
MRA of the neck without contrast$669$583$343
MRI of the abdomen$637$583$300
MRI of the abdomen with contrast$637$583$300
MRI of the abdomen without contrast$605$583$194
MRI of the ankle$637$583$261
MRI of the ankle with contrast$637$583$261
MRI of the ankle without contrast$605$583$222
MRI of the brain$637$583$269
MRI of the brain with contrast$637$583$269
MRI of the brain without contrast$605$582$195
MRI of the chest$637$583$371
MRI of the chest with contrast$637$583$371
MRI of the chest without contrast$669$583$466
MRI of the knee$637$1,165$315
MRI of the knee with contrast$637$583$315
MRI of the knee without contrast$605$1,165$204
MRI of the lower back (lumbar spine)$637$583$270
MRI of the lower back (lumbar spine) with contrast$637$583$270
MRI of the lower back (lumbar spine) without contrast$605$583$192
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine)$637$583$271
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine) with and without contrast$669$583$319
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine) with contrast$637$583$271
MRI of the mid-back (thoracic spine) without contrast$605$583$190
MRI of the neck (cervical spine)$637$583$274
MRI of the neck (cervical spine) with and without contrast$669$583$318
MRI of the neck (cervical spine) with contrast$637$583$274
MRI of the neck (cervical spine) without contrast$605$583$191
MRI of the pelvis$637$583$268
MRI of the pelvis with contrast$637$583$268
MRI of the pelvis without contrast$605$583$227
MRI of the shoulder$637$1,165$313
MRI of the shoulder with contrast$637$1,165$313
MRI of the shoulder without contrast$605$583$205
MRI of the wrist$637$1,165$330
MRI of the wrist with contrast$637$583$330
MRI of the wrist without contrast$637$1,165$303
Nebulizer breathing treatment$99$113$9
Nerve conduction study$47$1,582$118
Nuchal translucency ultrasound$126$325$116
Nuclear cardiac stress test$452$5,743$428
Occupational therapy evaluation$75$159$101
Occupational therapy evaluation (high complexity)$79$263$101
Occupational therapy evaluation (low complexity)$72$159$101
Occupational therapy evaluation (moderate complexity)$75$159$101
Office visit (established patient)$39$367$115
Office visit, established patient (level 3)$36$334$95
Office visit, established patient (level 4)$42$400$136
Pap smear (cervical screening)$29$194$20
Parathyroid hormone (PTH) test$72$305$41
Pelvic ultrasound$102$319$78
Pelvic ultrasound (complete)$102$343$105
Pelvic ultrasound (limited)$102$295$51
PET scan$1,576$6,043
Phosphorus blood test$8$98$5
Physical therapy evaluation$78$159$98
Physical therapy evaluation (high complexity)$82$279$98
Physical therapy evaluation (moderate complexity)$78$159$98
Platelet count$8$118$4
Pregnancy blood test (hCG)$13$189$8
Pregnancy ultrasound$102$505$126
Pregnancy ultrasound (first trimester)$102$478$117
Pregnancy ultrasound (second or third trimester)$102$531$136
Procalcitonin test$30$304$27
Prolactin test$34$407$19
Prostate test (PSA)$32$353$18
Psychotherapy session$47$85$140
Radiofrequency nerve ablation$619$3,311$462
Sacroiliac joint injection$228$2,219$176
Scoliosis spine X-ray$68$315$58
Scoliosis spine X-ray (1 view)$66$244$44
Scoliosis spine X-ray (3 views)$69$386$72
Screening mammogram$74$250$126
Scrotal ultrasound$102$382$99
Sedimentation rate (ESR) test$6$128$3
Sex hormone binding globulin test$38$214$22
Skin biopsy$75$457$121
Skin biopsy (punch)$75$457$121
Soft tissue ultrasound$96$281$64
Speech therapy$77$254$76
Spinal tap (lumbar puncture)$283$1,088$165
Spine fracture repair (kyphoplasty)$3,455$22,669$5,803
Spirometry (lung function test)$86$557$30
Spirometry with bronchodilator$195$937$43
Strep throat test$20$120$17
Stress echocardiogram$448$2,573$209
Stress echocardiogram (complete)$448$2,573$233
Swallow study$82$240$85
T3 thyroid test$25$364$14
Tdap (tetanus) vaccine$80$123
Testosterone test$45$410$26
Thyroid test (TSH)$29$301$17
Thyroid ultrasound$102$349$109
Thyroid uptake scan$452$1,061$145
Total IgE allergy test$29$248$16
Total protein test$6$74$4
Transesophageal echocardiogram (TEE)$371$2,855$239
Transesophageal echocardiogram (TEE) with and without contrast$448$2,855$239
Transvaginal ultrasound$102$331$118
Trigger point injection$241$604$56
Trigger point injection (1-2 muscles)$246$604$52
Triglycerides test$10$115$6
Troponin (heart) test$17$375$12
Turning a breech baby (version)$863$1,186$94
Upper GI series (barium)$68$682$128
Uric acid (gout) test$8$101$5
Urinalysis$5$118$3
Urine microalbumin test$9$173$5
Urine pregnancy test$11$160$9
Vaccine administration$20$108$19
Vaccine administration (each additional)$15$116$16
Vitamin B12 test$26$252$15
Vitamin D test$52$408$30
Wound debridement$297$2,748$186
X-ray of the abdomen$69$270$36
X-ray of the ankle$73$196$37
X-ray of the collarbone$69$192$33
X-ray of the elbow$73$258$33
X-ray of the facial bones$68$241$39
X-ray of the foot$73$195$34
X-ray of the forearm$69$367$29
X-ray of the hand$80$202$38
X-ray of the hip$69$275$49
X-ray of the hip (1 view)$66$173$34
X-ray of the hip (3 views)$69$275$49
X-ray of the hip (4 views)$73$377$63
X-ray of the knee$73$418$42
X-ray of the knee (2 views)$63$418$34
X-ray of the knee (3 views)$73$458$42
X-ray of the knee (4+ views)$80$262$49
X-ray of the lower back (lumbar spine)$68$293$47
X-ray of the lower back (lumbar spine) (2 views)$66$240$40
X-ray of the lower back (lumbar spine) (4+ views)$69$347$53
X-ray of the lower leg$69$397$31
X-ray of the mid-back (thoracic spine)$68$261$36
X-ray of the mid-back (thoracic spine) (2 views)$66$238$33
X-ray of the mid-back (thoracic spine) (3 views)$69$284$39
X-ray of the neck (cervical spine)$71$299$47
X-ray of the neck (cervical spine) (3 views)$69$250$40
X-ray of the pelvis$68$206$36
X-ray of the pelvis (1 view)$66$186$28
X-ray of the ribs$69$227$42
X-ray of the ribs (2 views)$66$205$36
X-ray of the ribs (3 views)$69$227$42
X-ray of the shoulder$73$391$36
X-ray of the skull$68$270$40
X-ray of the upper arm$69$362$32
X-ray of the wrist$76$516$43
Zinc blood test$20$245$11

Green = lower cash price. Source: hospitals' machine-readable files (45 CFR §180). Estimates — confirm with the hospital.